Halloween afternoon tea with brownies: 8 recipes to make at home

Are you looking for ideas for a Halloween afternoon tea featuring brownies? The quickest way is to use ready-made brownies and decorate them as graves, mummies or spiders in under 10 minutes. Here are 8 easy, eye-catching Halloween recipes that are perfect for making with the family on 31 October, without having to spend the afternoon in front of the oven.

Halloween snack

What to make for an easy Halloween snack

For an Halloween snack that’s easy, you need three things: colourful sweets, a drink and something savoury. The trick lies in setting aside the effort on decoration for the brownies and keeping the rest simple.

Always start with a ready-made base. A moist brownie holds its shape well when decorated, doesn’t crumble when cut, and everyone loves it. On top of that base, you can create almost any spooky character in just a few minutes, using four baking ingredients that you’re bound to have at home.

  • A sweet main course: a lovely Belgian chocolate brownie, like the ones from Mr Brownie, which serves as a canvas for decorating.
  • Two or three treats to go with it: jelly sweets, biscuits or seasonal fruit.
  • A themed drink: ‘potion’ juice, a chocolate milkshake or water with ice.
  • Something salty to balance it out: popcorn, mini sandwiches or corn cakes.

8 Halloween recipes featuring brownies for afternoon tea

These 8 Halloween recipes start with a ready-baked brownie and take between 5 and 15 minutes to put together, without turning the oven on. All you need is melted chocolate, sweet eyes, some colourful toppings and a bit of skill. Save the slices and the hot chocolate for the grown-ups; decorating is the fun part and anyone can do it.

Halloween-themed brownies

1. Brownie graves

Brownie graves are the simplest idea and the most visually appealing. Cut each brownie into a vertical rectangle, like a gravestone. Melt a little dark chocolate and, using a toothpick or a fine piping bag, write ‘RIP’ or ‘BOO’ on the front. Stick half a rectangular biscuit into the back to create a raised effect and sprinkle green chocolate shavings or coloured coconut around the edges to look like cemetery grass. You’ll have a tray ready in 5 minutes. If you want to go the extra mile, add a little jelly spider crawling up the gravestone.

2. Brownie mummies

Brownie mummies take just 8 minutes to make and never fail. Melt the white chocolate in a bain-marie or in the microwave, in 20-second bursts to prevent it from burning. Using a spoon or a piping bag, pipe thin, zigzagging lines onto the brownie, criss-crossing them like bandages and leaving a gap in the centre. Stick two caramel eyes into the gap. The contrast of the white chocolate against the dark brownie creates the mummy effect straight away. Leave them to set for five minutes in the fridge before moving them so that the bandages don’t smudge.

3. Spider brownies

Spider brownies are the biggest hit at the table. Place half a round chocolate, a whole walnut or a small chocolate ball in the centre of each brownie: this will be the spider’s body. From there, draw eight long, curved legs with melted chocolate, four on each side. Finish off with two caramel eyes on the body. If you have string liquorice, use it for the legs instead of chocolate and you’ll save time. With one spider per brownie, the whole tray looks like something straight out of a horror film.

4. Brownie pumpkins

Brownie pumpkins provide that signature orange colour of Halloween. Cut the brownie into circles using a cookie cutter or the rim of a glass, and cover with a thin layer of chocolate or orange-coloured icing. Draw the pumpkin face (triangular eyes and a jagged mouth) with dark chocolate and place a small piece of green liquorice on top as a tail. The ultimate shortcut? These Halloween brownies already come topped with pumpkin-shaped sweets, so you can serve them as they are or use them as a base and just add the little face.

5. Monstrous eyes

These monstrous eyes are terrifying and take just 5 minutes to make. Scatter caramel eyes of different sizes across the surface of the brownie, in no particular order, to make it look like a many-eyed creature. Connect them with thin strands of melted chocolate, as if they were veins, and add a couple of drops of red syrup or coloured sugar for a bloody effect. It’s the perfect recipe for using up any brownies that have broken whilst cutting: here, the mess is part of the charm and you won’t notice any imperfections.

6. Small earthenware cups from the cemetery

These ‘cemetery soil’ cups are both a dessert and a decoration. In a clear glass, place a layer of crumbled brownie, top with a spoonful of yoghurt, custard or cream, and cover it all with more crumbled brownie to look like ‘soil’. Stick a rectangular biscuit in as a gravestone and write ‘RIP’ with melted chocolate. Finish off with a couple of jelly worms peeking out of the soil. They take 10 minutes to make and can be left in the fridge until ready to serve, making them ideal for parties.

7. Brownie lollipops

Brownie lollipops are a hit as a sweet treat to take with you or as a little gift. Cut the brownie into cubes or shape it into small balls by pressing the crumb together with your hands. Push each piece onto a skewer or lollipop stick, dip it in melted chocolate and, before it sets, decorate it with coloured sprinkles, toffee eyes or white chocolate spider’s webs. Leave them to cool upright, stuck into a glass filled with sugar, for about 15 minutes to allow the chocolate to set. Wrapped in cellophane with a black bow, they look truly festive.

8. Brownie bats

Brownie bats are the quickest to make: 5 minutes per baking tray. Cut each brownie into a triangle or a circle to form the body. On either side, stick on two wings cut from a chocolate biscuit split in half, or draw them on with melted dark chocolate. Place two caramel eyes close together on top. If you use round chocolate biscuits cut in half as wings, they’re ready in no time and look really impressive. Arrange them so they peek over the edge of a plate, as if they were lying in wait.

This table summarises the 8 Halloween recipes, along with their preparation time, difficulty level and recommended age, so you can choose one based on how much time you have:

IdeaTime (min)DifficultyWhat else do you need apart from the brownie?Ideal for (age)
Brownie graves5EasyBiscuits and melted chocolate+4
Brownie mummies8EasyWhite chocolate and caramel eyes+4
Spider brownies10MediaChocolates and toffee eyes+5
Brownie pumpkins5EasyOrange topping or pumpkin sweets+3
Monstrous eyes5EasyCaramel eyes and red sugar+4
Cemetery earth cups10MediaYoghurt, jelly worms and biscuits+5
Brownie lollipops15MediaSticks, chocolate and coloured noodles+6
Brownie bats5EasyBiscuits or dark chocolate and eyes+4

Halloween brownies, ready to decorate

Mr. Brownie’s Halloween brownies are the quickest base for these recipes: they come ready-topped with pumpkin-shaped sweets and are individually wrapped, palm oil-free and GMO-free. Serve them as they are or use them as a canvas for your mummies and spiders, without dirtying a single frying pan. This way, you can put together a spooky spread even if you don’t have time to bake. You can view the full selection of brownies in the online shop.

How to set up the Halloween treats table

Set up your Halloween treats table with three ideas in mind: colour, height and signage. Choose two or three colours (orange, black and purple always work well) and spread them across tablecloths, glasses and sweets. Place the brownies at the front and at different heights, as they’re the ones that catch the eye the most.

To create different levels, use boxes or books covered in fabric or paper. Scatter cotton cobwebs, small pumpkins and a few lanterns around. Put up little signs with fun names: ‘witch’s fingers’, ‘vampire’s blood’ or ‘skeleton’s bones’. The eye is drawn to things first, so make sure each tray tells a story.

If you prefer a neutral base that goes with any décor, individual chocolate brownies work just as well: they’re quick to decorate and hold their shape throughout the whole afternoon tea.

How many sweets to prepare per guest

Allow 4 to 6 sweets per guest for a two-hour afternoon tea. It’s better to have a few left over than to run short: on Halloween, the sweets disappear in a flash.

For an afternoon tea party with 10 guests, prepare around 50 sweet treats in total and spread the selection across two or three different recipes. That way, you can offer variety without spending the whole afternoon in the kitchen. Always serve something savoury and a drink to balance the spread.

Halloween Brownies with Mr. Brownie

Frequently Asked Questions

What should you take to a Halloween tea party?

Bring along a colourful sweet treat that travels well, such as decorated brownies or brownie lollipops, plus a snack and a drink. Individually wrapped brownies are easy to carry and share, don’t make a mess, and will keep out of the fridge for the whole afternoon tea.

How do you decorate brownies for Halloween?

Decorate the brownies with melted chocolate, toffee eyes and colourful sprinkles. Draw cobwebs, mummy bandages or spider legs, or write ‘RIP’ on the graves. With just three or four basic ingredients, you can create eight different designs in a few minutes – no oven required.

Can Halloween desserts be made the day before?

Yes, most of these Halloween desserts are prepared the day before and kept in the fridge, covered, for up to 24 hours. Assemble the lollipops and the ‘cemetery soil’ cups the day before. Add the crunchy toppings just before serving so they don’t go soft.

How many brownies should you allow per guest at a party?

Allow 1 or 2 brownies per guest if there are other sweets on the table, and up to 2 or 3 if they’re the main dessert. For 10 guests, between 15 and 20 brownies are usually enough. Buy a few extra: at a Halloween party, people almost always go for seconds.

Which Halloween sweets are easy to make at home?

The easiest Halloween treats to make at home are those that just need decorating: graves, mummies, pumpkins and monster eyes. With sweet eyes and tempered melted chocolate, you can create various designs in minutes. Leave the cutting and the oven to an adult.

Celebrate Halloween with Mr Brownie

Put the finishing touch to your Halloween treat with Mr. Brownie’s Belgian chocolate brownies – a brand from Magdalenas Lázaro – which are light and fluffy and individually wrapped at the bakery in Alfamén (Zaragoza). The Halloween edition comes with a pumpkin topping, ready to set the spookiest table. Choose your favourite design, decorate and enjoy.